Shane Reiner-Roth is a writer and co-founder of Tall Work (Instrumental Plausibility). Through publications, exhibitions and speculative projects, his work examines the means by which certain objects appeal to an economy of expression by communicating higher values than their own on the cheap. He is currently a research fellow at the MIT department of architecture.

"The people of Los Angeles waited patiently for half a decade to make use of a useless site"

"The people of Los Angeles waited patiently for half a decade to make use of a useless site"

Featured on Dezeen

The battle of Oceanwide Plaza — a billion dollar tomb to foreign real estate speculation in the western corner of Downtown Los Angeles (DTLA) laid hollow since 2019, revived early this year by graffiti artists and paragliders that made it their nighttime playground, and nearly deadened once more by a City Council posturing against “urban misuse” — is a preview of the social and economic tensions that will increasingly take place across Los Angeles as it sprints towards the 2028 Summer Olympics. 

For anyone in need of visual evidence of regional wealth inequality in the present day, a visit to its downtown should do the trick. The pristine towers of international banks and oil companies in the Financial District twinkle in short distance from the tents of the growing unhoused population spilling beyond the sidewalks of Skid Row. The streets between the two enclaves are an ongoing contest for representation, as chauffeurs dodge panhandlers and skater punks to escort their clients directly to the front doors of exclusive restaurants and USC frat bar crawls leapfrog small businesses shuttered by staggering rent spikes.

The arrival of Staples Center (since renamed Crypto.com Arena) in 1999 launched a thousand developers to South Park, the western corner of DTLA bordering the Financial District, to construct venues for business and tourism far beyond the human scale. Rampant infill development transformed the sector into a questionable cultural destination, anchored by the steel and glass fortress structures of L.A. Live and the Los Angeles Convention Center, whose public displays of inequality are suppressed by an omnipresent security presence.

This course of development escalated during mid-2010’s rumors (and 2018 confirmation) that Los Angeles would host the Summer Olympics in 2028 (LA28), the third time the city would host the international event. 

NOlympics, a prominent local activist organization, spoke out against the decision, claiming that the Olympics “always accelerate policing, evictions, inequality, exploitation, and the erosion of democracy in every host city.” This was true when the Olympics were first held in Los Angeles in 1932, when law enforcement drove the poor out of the city at the height of the Great Depression, and it was true in 1984, when the second iteration ignited the racial and economic tensions precipitating the 1992 uprisings less than a decade later. 

The public sector of Los Angeles, meanwhile, has sworn to minimize the development of critical infrastructure, claiming the groundwork had been sufficiently laid during Olympics past, thus leaving it up to private enterprise to construct whatever it sees fit (compare this to other cities that have hosted, including London, Tokyo and Barcelona, which constructed thousands of average-priced housing units in anticipation of the games. Wholly unconcerned with history, international developers competed for the few remaining plots surrounding Crypto.com Arena, the future host of Olympic basketball games. 

Oceanwide Holdings, a Beijing-based publicly traded conglomerate, was one such operation that began construction in 2015 on Oceanwide Plaza across the street from the venue, at 1101 Flower Street. The $1 billion used to complete the glassy, 53-story-tall exteriors of the three towers defining the complex, designed to include luxury condominiums and a five-star Park Hyatt hotel above a three-story mall, was spent in vain, as construction was halted in 2019 due to “financing challenges” — one of the many risks of real estate speculation that should deter reckless development, but doesn’t. 

An obstructive eyesore barricaded on all sides, the towers were pillars of “urban misuse” for years before spray paint ever touched glass; the mind reels when considering all the more worthwhile things $1 billion could have funded in the city aside from a money pit. 

The people of Los Angeles waited patiently for half a decade to make use of a useless site. Unsanctioned spray paint, paragliding equipment, and rooftop steaks made Oceanwide Plaza a more vibrant site in reality than any marketing campaign ever could in imagination (these fervid efforts, fittingly enough, became a provocative backdrop to the 66th Annual Grammy Awards, the glitzy ceremony held in honor of an increasingly stratified industry, held across the street in early February). Videos endlessly shared on Instagram depict Oceanwide Plaza as a living organism whose facade changes appearance as routinely as a snake sheds its skin. 

It is only this type of “misuse,” of course, that could bring political urgency to 1101 Flower Street. While the protection of people is the message, the protection of property is the principle. The Los Angeles Police Department has already spent more than 3,000 hours at the site, buzzing its helicopters around the site to spotlight, and later arrest, dozens of occupants, while the Los Angeles City Council voted to allot nearly $4 million to remove the graffiti and reinforce the barricades. Another money pit, and an equally futile one, too, as graffiti artists have only since found new ways to enter the site. However apparent antagonisms were between economic classes across the whole of Downtown Los Angeles, the unfolding events at Oceanwide Plaza have spelled them out that much more plainly. 
The marketing team for LA28 doesn’t know how correct it is when it boasts that “LA is an infinite canvas to pursue your wildest dreams” (the irony of which is only intensified by the use of a graffiti-style ‘A’ in the LA28 logo). The energy visible on the facades of Oceanwide Plaza is that of the city itself; that fact has been laid bare by the local enthusiasm for their efforts. For the next four years, underserved Angelenos predicting their treatment by the city and private enterprise would be well advised to regularly check in on 1101 Flower Street.

Albert Frey’s 1931 Aluminaire House sits pretty at the Palm Springs Art Museum. Will its original intention shine through?

Albert Frey’s 1931 Aluminaire House sits pretty at the Palm Springs Art Museum. Will its original intention shine through?

Fired Up (New York Review of Architecture)

Fired Up (New York Review of Architecture)

0